Online shops nudge people into buying with design tricks called dark patterns. I studied how those tricks hurt users and the environment, with Amazon as the main case, and turned the findings into a guidebook for designers.
Read the full case study
The problem
E-commerce is everywhere, with giants like Amazon leading. These platforms often use dark patterns: interface designs built to push people into actions they would not otherwise take. Dark patterns are ethically questionable, and they also carry an environmental cost that almost nobody talks about.
My study looked at where sustainability, ethical design and e-commerce meet. I wanted to test whether ethical design changes could reduce both the manipulation and the ecological harm.
Three objectives
01Identify
Find and examine the dark patterns and environmental practices common in e-commerce, focusing on Amazon.
02Understand
Interview designers about ethical design, sustainability and dark patterns.
03Propose
Build a handbook of alternative designs that remove dark patterns and put sustainability first.
The questions I started with
- Is there a gap in user awareness about the environmental impact of using platforms, and about the influence of dark patterns?
- Should this awareness sit with users?
- Are there ways to raise awareness among users?
- Could awareness lead to more informed, more careful digital habits?
Objective 1: what the secondary research showed
Green UX
Green UX looks for ways to cut the digital waste that comes with e-commerce. In my secondary research, the internet's footprint was put at about 1.6 billion tonnes of greenhouse gases a year, with data centres adding roughly 2% to carbon emissions.
Amazon and sustainability
Amazon has invested in renewable energy and energy saving, yet still struggles to bring its footprint down. Most of that effort goes to logistics and data centres. The environmental impact of the digital platform itself, the website people click through every day, is mostly overlooked.
Dark patterns
E-commerce sites sway decisions with tactics like social proof, scarcity and forced continuity. Amazon has come under fire for enrolling customers in Prime without clear consent and making it hard to cancel, which the US Federal Trade Commission took up in a lawsuit.
Indian legal guidelines
I went through India's guidelines on dark patterns and marked the loopholes that still let these designs through.
The link
I mapped how dark patterns, the user and the environment connect, so the two harms could be looked at together instead of as separate topics.
Objective 2: what designers told me
I interviewed designers about three things: ethical design, sustainable design and dark patterns. After affinity mapping and thematic synthesis, three themes stood out.
Ethics lose to targets
- Pressure to hit short-term financial goals pushes ethics aside.
- Workplaces have no clear ethical framework.
- There is little training on ethics, so designers can slip into unethical practice without meaning to.
Dark patterns go unnoticed
- Many designers do not know enough about dark patterns to spot them.
- Weak legal frameworks let them persist.
- Deadlines and corporate pressure lead designers to repeat them.
Sustainability is an afterthought
- Short-term gains come before long-term sustainability.
- Awareness and education are low.
- Chances to design in eco-friendly ways are missed.
The turning point
The interviews changed my answers to the questions I started with.
Q1Yes, there is an awareness gap. It exists among designers too, not only users.
Q2No. Awareness should be built into designers first.
Q3User awareness matters, but we need more ways to reach designers.
Q4Aware designers lead to more informed, more careful users.
These are the designers who are designing our world, and awareness about digital environmental damage or even about dark patterns was so low. The more shocking point was that they worked in leading MNCs. That changed the course of the project, from raising awareness among users to raising it among designers.
Objective 3: redesigning 10 illegal dark patterns
I redesigned ten illegal dark patterns and, for each one, set out how the original harms users and the environment and how the alternative avoids it. One example is false urgency: countdowns and limited-time offers that rush people into buying.
How I tested the redesigns
- Survey with professionals. Designers looked at ethical and unethical screens side by side and marked agree, neutral or disagree against statements about each.
- Survey with users. People rated each interface from 1 to 5 across five kinds of manipulation, such as covert (influence you do not notice) and deceptive (information that leads you to a false belief).
- Interviews. I talked to users and experts to see whether both groups felt the same way about the designs.
The outcome: a guidebook in two parts
Checked
A checklist for UX/UI designers on how to design ethically and sustainably, built from the secondary research.
Redesign
The redesigned screens, each with an explanation of why it is more ethical and more sustainable than the original.
The guidebook has three goals: educate designers on eco-friendly and ethical practice, give them guidelines they can use, and encourage responsibility in everyday design work.
What I took from it
I began wanting to warn users. I ended up writing for designers, because they shape what users see. Fixing dark patterns and environmental harm sounds complicated, but the project shows it can be done with clear guidelines and without giving up on business goals. It also showed me how much depends on balancing respect for users with business interests.